Supercharge Your Pipeline: 5 Tips for Quality Candidate Feedback
Hiring

Supercharge Your Pipeline: 5 Tips for Quality Candidate Feedback

Want to Grow Your People Pipeline? Here’s How to Give Interview Feedback to Candidates The most common complaint from job seekers is a lack of constructive feedback. Considering that each candidate has invested time, energy, and hope into your organisation, it’s only fair and smart to understand how to give interview feedback to candidates in […]

March 20th, 2024
*

Abby.

Founder

A search expert making key hires for over twenty years.

Want to Grow Your People Pipeline? Here’s How to Give Interview Feedback to Candidates

The most common complaint from job seekers is a lack of constructive feedback. Considering that each candidate has invested time, energy, and hope into your organisation, it’s only fair and smart to understand how to give interview feedback to candidates in a way that’s thoughtful, clear, and constructive.

Why Feedback Matters

Many hiring managers feel unsure about how to give interview feedback to candidates, especially when the feedback isn’t glowing. As a result, candidates are often met with vague phrases like “you narrowly missed out” or “the role is now on hold.”

But providing specific, actionable feedback not only respects the time and effort of the candidate it strengthens your employer brand and increases the likelihood they’ll consider future roles with you.

Feedback = Experience = Brand

According to LinkedIn research, offering feedback after an interview improves the candidate experience by 40%. Even more compelling, 94% of candidates who receive feedback say they’re more likely to consider future opportunities with that employer.

That’s why learning how to give interview feedback to candidates is not just a “nice to have” it’s a vital part of building a high-performing, future-focused talent strategy.

Don’t Let Missed Hires Hurt Your Business

Once your ideal candidate accepts an offer, it’s tempting to move on quickly. But failing to properly close the loop with the rest of your shortlist is a missed opportunity.

In fact, neglecting to master how to give interview feedback to candidates can negatively impact brand perception and even future revenue. Candidates talk—and their experience becomes part of your company’s public reputation.

A Personal Take: The Long Game of Good Feedback

When I first started my career, my boss told me, “Always treat your candidates with respect they’ll come back to you one day.” She was right. Dozens of people I once gave detailed feedback to who didn’t get the role have returned years later as clients.

Learning how to give interview feedback to candidates has been one of the most career-defining skills I’ve built. It’s respectful, reputationally sound, and commercially smart.

Top Tips on How to Give Interview Feedback to Candidates

1. Offer to Schedule Feedback, Not Just Send It

When advising of the outcome, offer to book a short call to share insights.
Half will decline, but those who accept will appreciate it and remember you for it.

Framing feedback as a two-way conversation is a key part of understanding how to give interview feedback to candidates that feels constructive and not confrontational.

2. Prepare Detailed Notes

When providing feedback, it’s essential to be specific, constructive, and empathetic. Gather input from all interviewers and structure it in a way that focuses on behaviours not personality traits.

Phrases like “we felt you could have expanded more on…” or “I believe your strength lies in…” go a long way in creating an open and actionable conversation.

This level of clarity is central to best practice for candidates and supports their growth.

3. Encourage a Two-Way Conversation

Let the candidate share their perspective. Ask open-ended questions. Listen more than you speak.

Creating a space for dialogue helps candidates feel seen and respected. It also makes it easier for you to improve how you give interview feedback to candidates in the future.

4. Ask for Feedback in Return

Feedback is a two-way street. Ask candidates how they found your process and what could be improved.

By actively seeking this input, you show that you care about continuous improvement and you gain useful insight into how to give interview feedback to candidates that aligns with evolving candidate expectations.

5. Express Gratitude and Keep the Door Open

A simple thank you goes a long way. Acknowledge the time, energy, and interest the candidate brought to the process.

If appropriate, suggest staying in touch via LinkedIn or future roles. It’s a professional gesture that keeps your network warm and your pipeline active.

Why Feedback Is an Investment in Your Brand

Mastering how to give interview feedback to candidates is about more than kindness it’s about creating a ripple effect of trust, respect, and reputation. In a competitive hiring landscape, these are non-negotiable.

At Yellow Bricks, People Come First

At Yellow Bricks, we’re committed to hiring the best people in the market—and delivering an exceptional candidate experience.

We’re proud to place real change-makers in environments where they can thrive. Our goal is to build a purposeful, supportive community that drives positive change across businesses and careers alike.

Want help refining your candidate experience or interview process?

👉 Contact us today – and let’s build a better pipeline, together.

To find out more about how to focus on your brand, get in touch today.
Want to hear about our other articles?
Looking to hire your next superstar?
Keen to explore our latest vacancies?
Yellow Bricks is a female-owned and led executive search firm hiring predominately for software companies with diversity and inclusion at the heart of our offering. To learn more, click here.
Related posts
5 Ways of Managing Stress as a Leader

5 Ways of Managing Stress as a Leader

As a leader, your people will look to you for guidance in times of challenge and uncertainty.   Trying to manage your team as well as yourself during these times can make you vulnerable to high stress that can become chronic if not dealt with properly.   Currently, 69% of executives are considering quitting due […]
7 Ways to Communicate Better

7 Ways to Communicate Better

Are you a leader?   According to a Gallup survey, 70% of employee engagement is tied to the quality of communication from leadership. Communication is vital for driving organisational success. Whether you’re leading in a hybrid, remote, or full-time office environment, honing your communication skills is key to fostering engagement and collaboration. To help you […]
Executives, here are 9 ways to create a world-class personal brand

Executives, here are 9 ways to create a world-class personal brand

Your personal, professional brand. The strengths, characteristics, and achievements others remember you for.   It is an important deciding factor in how promotions and career opportunities play out.   But creating that brand and keeping it consistent is difficult — potentially more so than ever before.   Why does your brand matter in 2023?   […]
5 ways women can level up their careers

5 ways women can level up their careers

As the leader of an independent search firm, I am continually inspired by the exceptional talent and determination of women across various industries. Their resilience and ambition are driving positive change and reshaping the professional landscape.   Recent data highlights the significant progress we are making towards gender equality:   The gender pay gap continues […]
UK Visa Sponsorship: Explained

UK Visa Sponsorship: Explained

Employing a motivated, overseas worker: Not hard, not expensive   Immigration Law is often considered procedurally complex, expensive, and bureaucratic. I’ve omitted those parts to show employing an overseas worker doesn’t have to be a burden.   The following attempts to simplify a path for the employment of overseas nationals in the UK. To do […]
8 Proven Strategies to Accelerate Your Career Growth

8 Proven Strategies to Accelerate Your Career Growth

Reach Your Potential: 8 Actionable Tips for Career Growth Stuck in a rut? Do you feel like your career growth has slowed? You’re not alone, it’s been reported that 60% of employees no longer feel they are reaching their career potential. With a little self-ownership and some proactive effort, you can reignite your career growth […]
Investments in UK Tech Companies Hit New Highs

Investments in UK Tech Companies Hit New Highs

The UK has seen investments in tech reach £13.5 billion across 1400 companies this year alone, with record levels of investment predicted by the end of Q4 – very exciting news. It’s incredible to think that according to our research, in the first half of 2021, UK Tech Start-Ups attracted more venture capital interest than […]
5 career-boosting moves women can make

5 career-boosting moves women can make

As the leader of an independent search firm, I am privileged to witness, influence, and guide the remarkable achievements of women entering and excelling within leadership across diverse industries. The resilience, talent, and dedication I see daily is truly inspiring. Here I share my top 5 Career Growth Strategies for Women.   As we head […]
Remote Work: Is a New Norm Starting to Form?

Remote Work: Is a New Norm Starting to Form?

The COVID-19 pandemic brought about a seismic shift in the way we work, forcing millions of employees across the UK and around the globe to adapt to remote work practically overnight.   What began as a necessary response to a global health crisis has since evolved into a widespread reassessment of traditional work models, and […]
Your Blueprint to Building a Standout Personal Brand in 2024

Your Blueprint to Building a Standout Personal Brand in 2024

Your personal brand is more than just a catchy tagline; it’s the powerful reputation that precedes you, shaping how others perceive your skills, values, and achievements. In today’s competitive job market, a strong personal brand can make the difference in how promotions and career opportunities play out.   Why Does Your Brand Matter in 2024? […]

People. Culture. Growth.