First Interview Fails: The Mistakes Costing You A-Players
Career

First Interview Fails: The Mistakes Costing You A-Players

How to Make Candidates Feel Valued – From That Crucial First Hello The hiring landscape has shifted. We’re no longer solely in an employer’s market. Savvy candidates have choices, carefully selecting opportunities that align with their career aspirations. This well-needed rebalancing underscores a fundamental truth: the initial interview isn’t just about you evaluating talent; it’s […]

May 14th, 2025
*

Abby.

Founder

A search expert making key hires for over twenty years.

How to Make Candidates Feel Valued – From That Crucial First Hello

The hiring landscape has shifted. We’re no longer solely in an employer’s market. Savvy candidates have choices, carefully selecting opportunities that align with their career aspirations. This well-needed rebalancing underscores a fundamental truth: the initial interview isn’t just about you evaluating talent; it’s a pivotal moment for candidates to assess your company, too. Don’t fall at the first hurdle with first interview mistakes.

Here at Yellow Bricks, we’re seeing a growing trend. While companies increasingly manage their own recruitment, a critical element often gets lost in the process: genuine candidate feedback. So, how do those seeking their next big career move actually feel after that first interview? The answer, as leaders, might be unsettling. We frequently hear interviewers appear disengaged, unprepared, distracted, or simply rushing to tick a box. Imagine being that candidate, having invested time researching your brand, meticulously preparing to impress, perhaps even taking time off work, only to feel like an afterthought. It’s disheartening, to say the least.

Preparation, Empathy, and Experience: The Interviewer’s Cornerstones

Think about it from the candidate’s perspective. While an interview might be one of many on your calendar, for them, it’s a significant event. They’ve likely spent considerable time understanding how their skills and experience can contribute to your company’s purpose. Respecting that effort through thorough preparation on your part is paramount. Empathy plays a crucial role, too. Recognising the candidate’s potential anxieties and aspirations helps to create a more human, engaging interaction and avoid those first interview mistakes.

First Interview Mistakes – Poor First Impressions Can Cost You Dearly

The consequences of a lacklustre first interview extend far beyond a missed opportunity. Negative experiences are amplified in today’s interconnected world. Research shows that individuals with a bad experience are ten times more likely to share it with their network. This can significantly tarnish your employer brand, making it harder to attract leading talent in the future.

This is where a trusted recruitment partner like Yellow Bricks truly adds value. We bring expertise to the table, not only in identifying and attracting A-players – those individuals genuinely engaged with your vision and aligned with your goals – but also in meticulously managing the entire candidate experience. We ensure that whether you decide to move forward with a candidate or politely decline, the process is handled with professionalism and respect, providing valuable feedback that helps individuals on their journey towards their dream role.

Your Future Depends on Taking Hiring Seriously

Let’s be clear: the individuals you bring into your organisation will shape its future. Settling for less than the best, or assuming that the high-calibre talent you need doesn’t exist, is a dangerous gamble. Finding those “star players” requires a dedicated and strategic approach. Investing the time and effort to build a robust hiring process is not just a cost – it’s a fundamental investment in your company’s success.

Ready to elevate your hiring process and ensure every candidate feels valued? Let Yellow Bricks be your guide. Contact us today to discuss how we can help you attract and secure the A-players who will drive your business forward.

To find out more about how to focus on your brand, get in touch today.
Want to hear about our other articles?
Looking to hire your next superstar?
Keen to explore our latest vacancies?
Yellow Bricks is a female-owned and led executive search firm hiring predominately for software companies with diversity and inclusion at the heart of our offering. To learn more, click here.
Related posts
Why Leaders Need to Foster a Learning Culture

Why Leaders Need to Foster a Learning Culture

The pandemic brought a transformation to the working world, and as we enter the age of AI, businesses need to act now to future-proof themselves.   Going forward, the growth in technology and workers’ re-evaluations of their working lives means that incorporating a learning culture needs to become a top priority for organisations to future-proof, […]
First Interview Tips: 7 Simple Strategies for Success

First Interview Tips: 7 Simple Strategies for Success

Ace Your First Interview: 7 Proven Tips That Get Results! Improve your Interview Style, with these First Interview Tips: 7 Simple Strategies for Success. Navigating the job interview process can be a nerve-wracking experience, especially when it comes to that all-important first interview. It’s completely understandable to feel a mix of excitement and anxiety as […]
Yellow Bricks Story: Inspiring the Talent of the Future

Yellow Bricks Story: Inspiring the Talent of the Future

It is National Careers Week, often only celebrated within education establishments. What if we all did something amazing for the young people? What if we helped just one person each? Could a change happen?   It is hard to think about helping young people who are not your own. To justify doing something else with […]
Are You Ready for the Employment Law Overhaul?

Are You Ready for the Employment Law Overhaul?

As the Labour Party gears up to overhaul workers’ rights, UK businesses face a transformative shift in employment law. These forthcoming changes are set to redefine how companies manage their workforce and introduce new legal risks, particularly concerning employment tribunals. Here is a look at the anticipated reforms and how businesses can prepare for the […]
The Benefits to Hiring a Temp or Contractor

The Benefits to Hiring a Temp or Contractor

You have big ideas.   However, these ideas come with the need for an increased level of niche skill or time that your employees may not have.   What can you do?   Hire a temporary worker or an interim contractor:   What is a temporary worker / interim contractor?   An interim contractor is […]
6 Gender Biases in the Workplace and How We Can Address Them

6 Gender Biases in the Workplace and How We Can Address Them

As humans, we have biases.   They can be deliberate or unconscious and can impact all areas of society 🌍   They stem from stereotypes and assumptions we have about different groups of people.     Why do we rely on stereotypes? We have a conscious and unconscious mind that works in two different ways. […]
Is recruitment automation alienating top talent from you?

Is recruitment automation alienating top talent from you?

The rise of recruitment automation has undeniably streamlined many aspects of the hiring process. However, as technology continues to advance, a growing concern is emerging: the potential loss of human connection. Today’s top talent is increasingly feeling disconnected and undervalued as they navigate an increasingly automated job search. This disconnect is a significant risk to […]
7 Ways to Communicate Better

7 Ways to Communicate Better

Are you a leader?   According to a Gallup survey, 70% of employee engagement is tied to the quality of communication from leadership. Communication is vital for driving organisational success. Whether you’re leading in a hybrid, remote, or full-time office environment, honing your communication skills is key to fostering engagement and collaboration. To help you […]
Is this the real reason your people are leaving?

Is this the real reason your people are leaving?

We know that replacing key talent is a lot of work; when done badly, it can cost a lot of time and money.   Plus, the initial time, energy, and investment spent on hiring talent means it’s important to have effective retention strategies in place.   We polled 500 HR and people leaders, and 72% […]
How Should Employers Respond To Strikes?

How Should Employers Respond To Strikes?

Travel disruption is expected in the next few weeks. Train strikes are due for the end of July and middle of August due to rows over jobs, conditions, and pay. In the August strikes alone, 40,000 workers across Network Rail are expected to walk out. With trains being a popular mode of transport for workers, […]

Join 2,500+ forward-thinking leaders.

People. Culture. Growth.
Unlock your leadership potential with our biweekly newsletter. No spam, only gold.